We interviewed a grade 8 mathematics teacher from a middle school in the Coquitlam school district via e-mail. He had expressed the biggest challenge was trying to teach the basic operations such as addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division to the struggling students such that the students would not give up. Consequently, he would also have to keep the top students from being bored. For the top students, he allows them to be peer tutors and provides math challenges or puzzles for them. The math class schedules goes as: class game of Bus Driver, presentation of the math challenge, lecture (25 minutes) and assigned questions (30 minutes). Bus driver is a game with multiplication flash cards. These cards are never shuffled. The bus driver is the winner from the last game. They start off facing off another student in the class. Whoever is the fastest at answering the next flipped up card is the winner for that round. If it's a tie, the teacher keeps flipping the cards (sometimes many at a time) to see who is the fastest. The winner is the bus driver and goes to the next student. The game ends when everyone has a turn and is proclaimed the bus driver and has their name written on the board as the bus driver. Even the struggling students love participating and sometimes may guess the answer ahead of time to win.
By interviewing two students in different grades, we were able to observe some interesting similarities and differences in their responses. First half of the interview questions dealt with what the students like and not like about mathematics. When we asked them what their favourite parts in mathematics were, the grade 9 student responded that he likes to work with integers because they are straight-forward and it is easy to remember the rules. The grade 11 student responded that he likes algebra for a similar reason, but he also likes riddles and logic puzzles. It is interesting how the grade 9 student likes the straightforward and easy concept, while the grade 11 student likes the challenging puzzles and riddles that allow him to think beyond the simple rules and concept.
We then asked them to share some of the challenges they encounter in mathematics classes. The grade 9 student responded that one thing he finds really difficult is translating the word problems into the equations. Also, he is confused when the same symbols are used to represent different things. Similarly, the grade 11 student had a problem with understanding the idea behind the concepts and rules. For example, he has difficulties with understanding the differences between the inverse function and the reciprocal function. Some of these areas of difficulty in math reminded us of the articles that we have read by Skemp (1976) and Robinson (2006) stressing the idea of relational understanding instead of instrumental understanding. We thought that the students are having difficulties in those areas, because they lack the relational understanding of the concepts.
They also expressed an interest in class when the teacher used different media for explanations (that is, anything but the chalkboard). The use of geometric shape blocks on the projector depicting larger shapes and ideas was found as interesting. Presenting students with “challenge-of-the-week” (COW) puzzles and problems got the students interested in math beyond the daily lessons. With the grade 11 student, humour made the classroom more relaxed and the math lessons more interesting–but we can’t all be comedians! In the students’ opinions, logic puzzles would be an interesting addition to math classes. Real-life applications of math would also make the classes more practical. When asked about group work, the reactions were mixed. The grade 9 student did not prefer group work too much because of the added distractions from getting the work done. The grade 11 student has had math projects, such as designing a water slide using cubic functions, and enjoyed the idea of working with others, finding value in comparing answers and thought-processes with others.
Class contact list spreadsheet from Gigi
15 years ago
No comments:
Post a Comment